Production Directed By Matt DiCarlo
Original Broadway Direction By Mark Bell
Written By Henry Lewis,
Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields
Scenic Design Nigel Hook
Original Lighting Design Ric Mountjoy
Costume Design Roberto Surace
Original Sound Design Andrew Johnson
Original Music Rob Falconer
Production Lighting Design Jeremy Cunningham
Production Sound Design Beth Lake
Produced By Kevin McCollum   J.J. Abrams    Kenny Wax    Stage Presence Ltd.  Catherine Schreiber
Ken Davenport  Federman-Batchelder / deRoy-Brunish
Damian Arnold / TC Beech   Greenleaf Productions / Bard-Roth
Martian Entertainment / Jack Lane / John Yonover  Lucas McMahon

Jesse Aaronson  (Max)


(he/him) Jesse is thrilled to be returning to the Off-Broadway stage! Other credits: Yen (Raven Theatre) and A Christmas Carol (Drury Lane Theatre). Jesse is a proud graduate of the University of Michigan. His deepest thanks to Justin Picca, Stephen Kopel, and the incredible creative team. All my love to Mom, Dad, Samantha and Maureen. For Popsie. Instagram/TikTok: @iced__americano

Brent Bateman  (Robert)


National tour: Radio City Music Hall Christmas Spectacular. Regional: Pennsylvania Shakespeare Festival, Hartford Stage, Theatre Under the Stars, Asolo Repertory Theatre, North Shore Music Theatre, Theatre by the Sea, Westchester Broadway Theatre, North Carolina Theatre, Triad Stage, Ogunquit Playhouse, Arrow Rock Lyceum, Riverside Theatre. Film/TV: Birdman, Touched With Fire, “Boardwalk Empire,” “Blue Bloods,” “The Good Fight.” MFA, FSU/Asolo Conservatory for Actor Training. Thanks to Bret Adams Limited. Endless love and gratitude to Katie.

Bartley Booz  (Dennis, U/S Trevor)


Off-Broadway debut! Theatre: For Annie (The Hearth), Park Plays (Queens Theatre), Little League (Kraine Theatre). Film/TV: "The Good Fight" (CBS),“Happy!” (Syfy), Here and Now (Tribeca FF), “TURN: Washington’s Spies” (AMC). BFA Acting CCM University of Cincinnati.

Ryan Vincent Anderson  (Trevor)


(he/him) Off-Broadway: Scissoring (INTAR), We Live Here (Ensemble Studio Theatre), Bright Swords (United Solo Fest). Regional: Oregon Shakespeare Festival, Marin Theatre Company, PCPA, L.A. TheaterWorks, Theatresquared, Independent Shakespeare Company, Portland Center Stage, A Noise Within, Antaeus Theatre Company and others. TV: “Law & Order: SVU,” “The Sinner,” “FBI,” “Godfather of Harlem,” “Scandal,” “General Hospital,” “The Young and the Restless.” Audiobook narration titles can be found on Amazon/Audible. MFA from CalArts.

Chris Lanceley  (Jonathan)


(he/him) Born in Liverpool, England, Chris’ work includes National Tour: The Play That Goes Wrong, Off-Broadway: The Bad and the Better. Off-West End: Henry V, The Band. TV: “FBI,” “Blue Bloods.” Training: American Academy of Dramatic Arts (NYC), National Youth Theatre of Great Britain. Chris would like to extend a HUGE thank you to agent John Shea as well as to his wife Jenny, Dad, Nan, Kim and Nick. Social Media: @Chris_Lanceley.

Matt Harrington  (Chris Bean)


Broadway: Mr. Wormwood in Matilda the Musical, Twelfth Night and Richard III, Harvey. Off-Broadway: Happy Birthday, Wanda June (Wheelhouse Theater Company). Regional: Cape Playhouse, Philadelphia Theatre Company, Berkshire Theatre Festival, TheatreWorks Palo Alto, Portland Stage, Weston Playhouse, Syracuse Stage. TV: “The Path,” “Instinct,” “Boardwalk Empire,” “Bored to Death,” “The Good Wife,” “Gravity.” Matt is a founding member of Wheelhouse Theater Company and is available for audition coaching in NYC. Training: MFA, NYU’s Graduate Acting Program.

Ashley N. Hildreth  (Annie)


Ashley N. Hildreth is excited to be joining the cast of TPTGW! Her recent credits include Protest, Plans, and Red Velvet Brownies (True Colors Theatre Company); The Wolves (Actors Theatre of Louisville); Or, What She Will (Hangar Theatre). Training: BFA, Texas State University; PTC at The Actors Theatre of Louisville. She would like to thank the TPTGW team, HCKR Agency and her family and friends for their continued love and support., @ashleynhildreth. 1 Peter 4:10

Maggie Weston  (Sandra)


(she/her) Maggie Weston is over the moon to be back and part of this stellar cast! Reg. credits: It’s a Wonderful Life (Mile Square Theatre), Shear Madness (Southeastern Summer Theatre), Fifty Four Forever (with Tommy Tune), Metamorphoses (The Adrienne Arsht Center). TV: “Happy!,” “Awkwafina...,” “FBI: Most Wanted,” "Law & Order: SVU.” Film: Call Jane. BFA UMiami. Astronomic thanks to Stephen Kopel, the creative team, Mom, Dad, Casey, my godparents and Gidge. @Ms.MaggieWeston /

Damien Brett  (Understudy)


(he/him) Damien is thrilled to be back in Haversham Manor at New World Stages! Broadway: Kinky Boots. National tours: Kinky Boots (original cast); Billy Elliot. Regional: Paper Mill Playhouse (Annie); St. Louis Muny (28 different productions). Television: “Law & Order: SVU," "The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel." Film: Edward Norton’s Motherless Brooklyn. Favorite roles ever: husband to Briana Valerie and daddy to Olive Rose. Thanks to my amazing family and to Dani Super Management.

Laura D'Andre  (Understudy)


Laura is thrilled to be reunited with her Wrong family! Broadway national tours: Hair, Grease. Encores!: Annie Get Your Gun, Zorba. Select Regional: Hair (Sacramento Music Circus), Legally Blonde (Ogunquit), Triangle (world premiere, TheatreWorks), Smokey Joe’s Café (Capital Rep). Thank you to the creative team, Stephen Kopel and Avalon Artists Group. All the love to my family for their support, especially my husband for putting our baby to bed. @lauradandre

Ellie MacPherson  (Understudy)


Off-Broadway debut! Ellie is also the creator and performer of a one-woman comedic history of the presidents called Happy Birthday Mr. President! BA in History and English from Rutgers, MFA New School for Drama. Endless love and gratitude to the whole TPTGW team, my family, and Lucas. @ellmac5.

Sid Solomon  (Understudy)


(he/him) National Tour: The Play That Goes Wrong. Select credits: Julius Caesar, The Comedy of Errors, Romeo and Juliet (The Acting Company/Guthrie Theater); The Woman In Black (Virginia Stage); Disgraced (Northern Stage); God of Isaac (Florida Studio); Over The River... (Riverside); Hamlet (Georgia Shakespeare); 1001 (Mixed Blood). TV: “Law and Order”. Training: B.F.A., University of Minnesota/Guthrie Theater; LaGuardia Arts High School, New York. Proud member and officer of Actors’ Equity Association. For Gigi.

WHITNEY M. KEETER  (Production Stage Manager)


(she/her) National tours: The Play That Goes Wrong, Something Rotten! Off-Broadway: Orwell in America, Trick or Treat, Brits Off-Broadway. Regional: The Engagement Party (Hartford Stage); Into the Woods, The Hound of the Baskervilles (Northern Stage); Shrek, Dirty Rotten Scoundrels, Spamalot, A Little Night Music, Singin’ in the Rain, Les Misérables, Hair (New London Barn Playhouse); Macbeth, God of Carnage, A Midsummer Night’s Dream (Alabama Shakespeare Festival). For Nicholas.

T.J. KEARNEY  (Assistant Stage Manager)


(he/him) Broadway: The Lightning Thief; Deaf West’s Spring Awakening. Tours: The Lightning Thief; Radio City Christmas Spectacular. Off-Broadway: As You Like It (CSC); Charlie Brown (York). Regional: 42nd Street (Bucks); Newsies, Hairspray, Producers (Maltz); My Fair Lady (Bay Street); Steward of Christendom, Humor Abuse, Leap of Faith, Girlfriend (CTG); Merrily We Roll Along, Deaf West’s Spring Awakening (Wallis); Twist! (Pasadena); Six Dance Lessons, This Wonderful Life (Laguna). Founding member of The Forest of Arden. BFA from CalArts.

ERIN MAUREEN KOSTER  (Assistant Stage Manager)


Off-Broadway: New York Theatre Workshop, Irish Repertory, Atlantic Theater Company, The Public, Roundabout, Lincoln Center, Classic Stage, Epic Theatre Ensemble, amongst others. Regional: New York Stage & Film, Williamstown, Bay Street. Erin is a show caller and deck stage manager for large-scale events, a company member of Caborca Theatre, a proud councilor of Actors’ Equity Association and a mom.

× × < >